Local Team Applies Archeological Forensic Anthropology Science to Dragoon's Butterfield Station and Beyond!

Text and images copyright www.DragoonArizona.com  

unless otherwise noted                                                                     

Archaeological forensic anthropology is a specialized field that combines principles of forensic anthropology with archaeological methods to analyze human remains in historical or ancient contexts. It focuses on recovering, identifying, and interpreting skeletal remains from archaeological sites to understand past populations, their lives, and their deaths, often with a focus on legal or historical significance.

 

Meet Mark and Karen. Native to Willcox and Pearce, they now live in Tucson and provide services all across the USA as well as internationally. They have canvassed the Dragoon station area from multiple different angles, at different times, under different atmospheric conditions, using different applications of the same scientific principles of archaeological forensic anthropology. They have clearly established where human remains are located and where they are not at the Butterfield Dragoon station. This is not some folks with a dog that thinks it can find a bone. This is the science of VOC's (volatile organic compounds) sourced from human remains as they change and evolve in the soil and localized environment, over thousands of years. YES, THOUSANDS! 

 

The science is solid. So solid in fact that it is admissible in court! 

 

And they now use the Dragoon Station as a training ground for their extreme front line technicians, Polly & Breicne, their Border Collies, to sharpen their archaeological forensic anthropology skills. 

 

Need to contact them directly? kpaquette1@comcast.net mpaquette1@comcast.net 

Want more on their organization for which they work? https://www.firstdetectionk9.org/ 

 

Archaeological forensic anthropology definition and scope:

  • Forensic Anthropology: The application of anthropological and skeletal analysis to identify unknown individuals, determine cause of death, or estimate biological profiles (age, sex, stature, ancestry) in a medico-legal context.
  • Archaeological Context: When applied to archaeology, forensic anthropology adapts these techniques to analyze remains from historical or ancient sites, often where no legal case exists but where understanding past events (e.g., mass burials, battles, or rituals) is crucial.
  • The field bridges modern forensic science with archaeological recovery techniques to study human remains that may be centuries or millennia old.

Key Objectives

  1. Recovery of Remains: Using archaeological excavation techniques to carefully locate, document, and retrieve skeletal remains while preserving context (e.g., burial position, associated artifacts).
  2. Identification: Estimating biological characteristics such as age, sex, stature, and ancestry through skeletal analysis.
  3. Trauma Analysis: Examining bones for evidence of injury, violence, or cause of death (e.g., weapon marks, fractures).
  4. Pathology and Health: Identifying diseases, malnutrition, or other health conditions from skeletal evidence to infer lifestyle or societal conditions.
  5. Cultural and Historical Interpretation: Reconstructing burial practices, social structures, or historical events (e.g., mass graves from wars or epidemics).
  6. Legal Applications: In some cases, analyzing remains from recent historical contexts (e.g., war crimes, genocides) to provide evidence for legal proceedings.

Methods and Techniques

  • Excavation: Precise archaeological methods ensure remains and associated artifacts are recovered without damage. This includes mapping, stratigraphic analysis, and documentation.
  • Skeletal Analysis: Techniques like osteometry (measuring bones), dental analysis, and morphological assessment to estimate biological profiles.
  • Taphonomy: Studying post-mortem changes to bones (e.g., weathering, animal scavenging) to understand the time since death and environmental impacts.
  • Advanced Technologies:
    • Radiography/CT scans: To detect internal bone structure or trauma.
    • Isotope Analysis: To infer diet, migration, or geographic origin.
    • DNA Analysis: To identify genetic relationships or ancestry (if preservation allows).
  • Comparative Analysis: Comparing findings with historical records, artifacts, or other archaeological data to contextualize remains.

Applications

  • Historical Insights: Studying ancient burials to understand cultural practices, social hierarchy, or demographic patterns (e.g., analyzing Roman or Medieval cemeteries).
  • Mass Grave Investigations: Examining remains from historical conflicts, genocides, or disasters (e.g., World War II mass graves or plague pits).
  • Repatriation: Identifying remains for return to descendant communities, often in collaboration with indigenous groups or cultural organizations.
  • Legal Cases: Providing evidence in cases involving historical crimes or unidentified remains from recent history.

Challenges

  • Preservation: Ancient remains may be degraded, limiting analysis.
  • Contextual Gaps: Lack of historical records can make interpretation difficult.
  • Ethical Considerations: Balancing scientific study with respect for cultural or descendant sensitivities, especially in repatriation cases.
  • Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Requires expertise in archaeology, anthropology, history, and sometimes forensic science.

 

Image above copyright www.firstdetectionk9.org/ 

GPS Collar

Polly and Karen, taking a break

Working with Mark, Breicne, marks human remains

Something smells interesting! 

Grid system for systematic data documentation

Grid system for systematic data documentation

Searching the grid

The Science of Forensic Anthropology

Forensic anthropology is a specialized subfield of anthropology that applies the principles of physical anthropology, archaeology, and related sciences to analyze human remains in a legal context, primarily to assist in identifying deceased individuals and determining the circumstances of their death. It combines expertise in human skeletal biology, anatomy, and osteology with forensic science to aid law enforcement, medical examiners, and coroners in criminal investigations, mass disasters, or historical cases.

 

Below is the science umbrella under which Archaeological Forensic Anthropology can be found.

 

Want more information? See the bottom of the page for more! 

 

 

Image to the right: Polly taking a well deserved break!

 

Forensic anthropology is a specialized subfield of anthropology that applies the principles of physical anthropology, archaeology, and related sciences to analyze human remains in a legal context, primarily to assist in identifying deceased individuals and determining the circumstances of their death. It combines expertise in human skeletal biology, anatomy, and osteology with forensic science to aid law enforcement, medical examiners, and coroners in criminal investigations, mass disasters, or historical cases.

 

Key Aspects of Forensic Anthropology:

 

  1. Identification of Human Remains:
    • Forensic anthropologists analyze skeletal remains to estimate biological profiles, including:
      • Age: Determined through skeletal development (e.g., epiphyseal fusion in younger individuals) or degenerative changes (e.g., arthritis in older individuals).
      • Sex: Assessed using features like pelvic shape, skull morphology, or bone robusticity.
      • Stature: Estimated from long bone measurements.
      • Ancestry: Inferred from cranial and skeletal features, though this is complex and often supplemented with genetic analysis.
    • They also identify unique markers, such as healed fractures, dental records, or surgical implants, to confirm identity.
  2. Cause and Manner of Death:
    • By examining trauma on bones (e.g., fractures, gunshot wounds, or cut marks), forensic anthropologists can infer whether injuries occurred before (antemortem), around the time of (perimortem), or after (postmortem) death.
    • They distinguish between blunt force, sharp force, ballistic, or thermal trauma, helping to classify the manner of death (e.g., homicide, suicide, accident, or natural).
  3. Time Since Death:
    • Estimating the postmortem interval (PMI) involves analyzing the condition of remains, such as decomposition stage, bone weathering, or insect activity, often in collaboration with forensic entomologists.
  4. Recovery of Remains:
    • Forensic anthropologists use archaeological techniques to locate, excavate, and recover skeletal remains from crime scenes, mass graves, or disaster sites, ensuring evidence is preserved.
  5. Mass Disasters and Human Rights:
    • They assist in identifying victims in mass disasters (e.g., plane crashes, natural disasters) or human rights investigations (e.g., genocide cases) by analyzing remains from mass graves or scattered sites.
  6. Technological Tools:
    • Common tools include 3D imaging, CT scans, DNA analysis, and isotopic studies to refine identification or provide contextual clues (e.g., geographic origins from stable isotopes in bones or teeth).

Applications

  • Criminal Investigations: Identifying unknown remains, analyzing trauma, and providing expert testimony in court.
  • Missing Persons Cases: Matching remains to missing individuals using skeletal and dental records.
  • Historical or Archaeological Cases: Analyzing ancient or historical remains for repatriation or academic study, when a legal context applies.
  • Disaster Victim Identification (DVI): Assisting in large-scale identification efforts post-disaster.

Education and TrainingForensic anthropologists typically hold advanced degrees (master’s or Ph.D.) in anthropology with specialized training in forensic science. Certification by the American Board of Forensic Anthropology (ABFA) is a recognized standard in the U.S., requiring rigorous testing and casework experience.

 

Breicne is ready to work! Lets go Mark!

Systematically working the grid! 

Pre-meeting to start the day!

Want more information?

 

 

Contact Mark or Karen directly at kpaquette1@comcast.net mpaquette1@comcast.net 

 

Need to find someone deceased recent or historical? Contact First Detection K9 at  https://www.firstdetectionk9.org/ 

 

Forensic Anthropology Center 

https://www.txst.edu/anthropology/facts/aboutus.html 

 

Forensic Anthropology Research Facility 

https://www.txst.edu/anthropology/facts/labs/farf.html 

 

Osteology Research and Processing Laboratory

https://www.txst.edu/anthropology/facts/labs/orpl.html 

 

Grady Early Forensic Anthropology 

https://www.txst.edu/anthropology/facts/labs/gefarl.html